Is a budget Amazon violin package worth it for beginners? Discover the differences in set-up, sound quality, and long-term value between factory instruments and professional shop set-ups.
Should You Buy a Violin on Amazon or From a Professional Violin Shop?
There are many differences between a violin package from Amazon/eBay and one from a professional shop like the Paul A. Schmitt Violin Shop. To name a few, the quality of the wood and make as well as the set-up quality are some of the most important ones which lead to long-term playability.
Amazon instruments arrive with factory set-ups which are not measured and fitted to each instrument; they may have uneven bridge heights, sticking pegs, even incorrect strings. Although they may have a more attractive price, they will require a lot more in repair and set-up costs than the value of the instrument and still won’t have the same quality as a professionally set-up student level instrument. However, instruments from a professional violin shop are individually assessed and adjusted by luthiers. This ensures the instrument is physically easier to play and capable of producing a resonant, clear tone—essential factors that prevent beginners from becoming frustrated and quitting early in their musical journey.
The Professional Set-Up Advantage
When you purchase a violin through a major online retailer that doesn’t specialize in string instruments, you are typically receiving a "factory set-up" or an "out-of-box" product.
Every instrument in the Paul A. Schmitt Violin Shop is worked on by a team of eight in-house luthiers. These experts ensure the instrument is up to the specific standards of the shop rather than relying on how it left a factory.
One of the reasons that differentiates the Paul A. Schmitt Violin Shop from other shops is that string specialists like Niloofar and Josh are professionally trained musicians and active performers in the community. They personally test the instruments to ensure the sound quality meets professional expectations, across all skill levels. A shop-verified instrument will utilize quality materials from trusted sources and manufacturers. They will receive a high-quality set-up, which includes smooth turning pegs, proper string action, and hand-carved bridge and sound post to ensure the instrument’s playability and structural integrity, along with many other specifications.
The Hidden Cost of "Cheap" Instruments
For adult beginners, a $200 package can seem like a low-risk entry point. However, an entry-level instrument that hasn't been properly vetted can actually hinder progress.
Schmitt Music offers an Advance Orchestra Plan, which serves as the first step out of basic entry-level instruments. The value in a $1,500+ instrument lies in the materials and the precision of the build. Higher-quality tone woods and expert craftsmanship allow the player to grow into the instrument.
Furthermore, for those worried about the high cost of committing to a purchase, the "Better Than Rent" program is created to help students and their families build equity with the company. This is a crucial distinction: an Amazon purchase is a sunk cost, whereas a shop instrument often carries equity that can be transferred if a student decides to upgrade or switch instruments.
Choosing Between Brands: Eastman 315 vs. Lake City Ellie Claire
When comparing reputable brands like Eastman and Lake City, the choice often comes down to individual preference and the specific "voice" of the instrument rather than just the brand.
Eastman 315 Violin
Known for consistent quality and being a staple in school orchestra programs across the Midwest.
Lake City Ellie Claire Violin
An exclusive brand that is optimized specifically for students and advancing players.
Since no two violins sound exactly alike—even within the same model—professional shops recommend an interactive approach. If you cannot come into the store to try them in person, the specialists at the Paul A. Schmitt Violin Shop can facilitate in-home trials and play-testing videos to help walk customers through the process remotely, ensuring the instrument matches the player's needs.
Why Expert Sourcing Matters
Working with a specialty shop connects you to a network of expertise. The Paul A. Schmitt Violin Shop works with nationally renowned luthiers and maintains connections with school districts, performing art programs, private instructors, and performers across the Midwest. Teachers often provide specific requirement lists, and a professional shop is equipped to match those needs exactly, whereas a generic online listing may miss critical specifications required for successful musical endeavors.
Expert Advice, Just a Message Away
From instruments to accessories and everything in between, our experts can help you find exactly what you need. Message us anytime.