FREE SHIPPING

On most orders in the Contiguous U.S.
Exclusions apply, including pianos & freight items.

SHIPSONATA

B-Flat & A Clarinet: When to Expand for Orchestra

B-Flat & A Clarinet: When to Expand for Orchestra

Melissa Morales |

The Orchestral Requirement: Why One Clarinet Isn't Enough

If you started your musical journey in a school band program, chances are you play a B-flat clarinet. As the standard instrument for school bands, the B-flat is the foundation for most clarinetists. But as you branch into youth orchestras, community orchestras, collegiate music programs, and professional performance, another instrument often becomes essential: the A clarinet.

Dr. Melissa Morales, clarinet specialist at the Schmitt Music Clarinet Gallery, explains that while the B-flat clarinet is slightly shorter and widely used in school settings, the A clarinet—or the “tall boi” of the pair—is an important tool for orchestral and advanced solo and chamber repertoire.

“If you are playing in a youth orchestra, a community orchestra, or a professional orchestra—or if you are majoring in music—you need an A clarinet to get through the program,” Dr. Morales explains.

For serious students pursuing classical music, owning both instruments is more than a luxury. It is often a practical necessity for the repertoire they will encounter.

A Clarinet vs. B-Flat Clarinet: Key Differences

At first glance, the two instruments look remarkably similar, but each has an important role in the clarinet repertoire.

  • Physical Size: The A clarinet is slightly longer than the B-flat clarinet.
  • Key and Pitch: The B-flat clarinet is pitched in the key of B-flat, whereas the A clarinet is pitched in A. Both instruments use the same fingering system but produce pitches a half step apart when playing the same written pitches.
  • The “Friendly Key” Factor: One of the primary reasons both instruments remain in use is that certain musical passages are more comfortable to play on one instrument than the other.

When the clarinet first developed, its limited keywork made playing in certain keys considerably more difficult than others. Building instruments of different lengths helped composers and performers navigate these challenges. Although modern clarinets have sophisticated key systems that allow players to perform in every key, the A clarinet remains an important part of orchestral tradition.

Many composers wrote specifically for the A clarinet, and its slightly different tonal characteristics also contribute to its continued use. Switching between A and B-flat clarinets can make certain passages more manageable under the fingers while preserving the musical character and performance tradition associated with the instrument.

The Professional Advantage: Simplified Technique

One of the biggest misconceptions for students is that playing an A clarinet requires learning an entirely new set of skills. Fortunately, that isn't the case.

“The fingerings are exactly the same,” says Dr. Morales. “We use the same exact fingerings...it's just sounding a different pitch.”

Because the fingering system remains essentially the same, clarinetists can move between the two instruments without learning a new set of fingerings. The written music is adapted to each instrument's transposition, allowing players to use familiar technique across both.

Players generally don't need a separate set of accessories for each clarinet, either. The same mouthpiece, reeds, and ligature can typically be used for both B-flat and A clarinets. Some players even use the same barrel, provided it is compatible with both instruments and supports the desired tuning. This makes maintaining a professional clarinet setup more manageable and helps keep the investment in additional equipment under control.

Is It Time to Upgrade?

For players pursuing advanced repertoire and orchestral opportunities, the A clarinet becomes an important part of the toolkit. Whether you’re preparing for an audition, exploring orchestral repertoire, or enjoying chamber music with friends, an A clarinet lets you play music written for the instrument in its intended key, without needing to transpose the part yourself.

While modern clarinets can play in every key, the A clarinet remains an essential part of orchestral tradition. For many advanced players, having both instruments available makes preparing and performing the repertoire more practical.

Dr. Morales highlights the Yamaha CSVR as a flagship model for players ready to make this investment. Its craftsmanship, consistency, and tonal qualities make it a compelling option for musicians preparing to explore the demands of orchestral repertoire.

Watch now! › Clarinet Gallery's DOS Melissa with clarinets in the background

Planning Your Trial at the Clarinet Gallery

Choosing an A clarinet is a personal process. You'll want an instrument that feels comfortable, responds well to your playing, and—just as importantly—matches your B-flat clarinet. The Schmitt Music Clarinet Gallery in Bloomington offers a “musician's wonderland” where players can compare different models side-by-side and find the right fit for their musical needs.

If you are ready to explore the “tall bois,” Dr. Morales and the Clarinet Gallery team offer specialized consultations to help you find an A clarinet that complements your B-flat instrument. Whether you visit us in person or take advantage of our remote trial programs, we're here to help you find an instrument that feels like a natural extension of your playing.

Royal Global MAX Pro A & Bb Clarinets

Royal Global MAX Pro A and Bb Clarinet

Yamaha CSVR Bb A Clarinet

Yamaha CSVR Bb & A Clarinet


Ready to find your A clarinet? Make an appointment with the Schmitt Music Clarinet Gallery!

When you visit, bring your B-flat clarinet, your usual mouthpiece, reeds, ligature, and any other essential accessories you use in your regular setup. Most importantly, bring music you know really well: something lyrical that lets you explore the instrument's tone and response, and something technical that puts its articulation, evenness, and facility to the test.

The goal is to challenge the clarinet, not your memory! When you can play comfortably without thinking too hard about the notes, you can focus on what really matters: how the instrument feels, responds, and sounds in your hands.

We'll compare your A and B-flat clarinets side-by-side to help you find a match that inspires confidence, supports your musical growth, and makes you excited to play—and your audience excited to listen.